Fiction · Historical

City of Girls


Title: City of Girls

Author: Elizabeth Gilbert

Page Count: 470

Series: N/A

Publishing Date/Publisher: June 4, 2019 by Riverhead

Format: Hardcover

Review: This was a firm 3 star read for me.  In other words, I liked it, but I did not love it.  This book is billed as a “love story,” however, I would hardly consider it a romance.  In fact, I wouldn’t even tag it as romance.  In a lot of ways this story reminded me of the TV series How I Met Your Mother.  Vivian, our protagonist, is writing the story to Angela, the daughter of her deceased love.  Angela has reached out to Vivian to ask about the nature of her relationship with her father and Vivian answers in a very prolonged and roundabout way.  She includes many details that are of no relevance to how she met Angela’s father.  For the most part, I found Vivian to be a rather unlikeable character, at least for about 60% of the book.  Life circumstances make her grow as a character, but I never truly became endeared to her.  The last 25% of the book was by far the most enjoyable part of the story, but after all the build up to meeting Vivian’s father, I was a bit disappointed with how little page time he actually got.  So as I said, this wasn’t really a love story, but a story about Vivian.  This is not to say that the book made no impression on me whatsoever.  Gilbert is undeniably a gifted writer and there were enough things I liked about the book to keep reading it.  For one thing, I was extremely envious of Vivian’s skill with a sewing machine, and I almost want to take a sewing class as a result.  I was fascinated by the way she talked about fabric and clothing and design.  This book also had a lot of really good one liners sprinkled throughout and some very memorable characters, such as Aunt Peg.  It was enough to keep me moving through the book at a steady pace, and certainly enough to inspire me to finish it.  This book certainly has it’s share of scandal, but it’s not particularly graphic, and it really tackles the double standard that men and women are held to when it comes to sexuality.

Reader: Bekah



One thought on “City of Girls

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s